China is facing one of the most alarming fertility declines in the world, and Jim Penman explains why the problem is now beyond the reach of government incentives or control.
In this episode, Jim outlines how culture, prosperity, and changing social values combine to drive the global birth rate crisis.
His insights reveal why China’s policies fail and why technology and neuroscience may be the only long-term solution.
Introduction
This episode of Conversations with Jim Penman focuses on China and its role in the global birth rate crisis.
Jim explains why China, despite a strong central authority, cannot reverse its falling birth rate and why the same pattern is emerging across developed nations.
Understanding this issue matters because China is home to more than one billion people and plays a major role in global economic stability.
As Jim explains, China’s demographic decline will shape international markets, political relationships, and the world economy.
To explore more commentary from Jim, visit the Jim’s Group website.
China once used strict population limits to reduce fertility.
Now it struggles to encourage even two children per family.
Jim says this reversal highlights the deeper psychological and cultural forces shaping the global decline.
What Does China Reveal About the Limits of Government Power?
China has one of the most powerful and controlled societies in the world.
Jim explains that this makes its demographic failure even more significant.
Governments can stop people from having children, but they cannot make them have more.
For decades, China enforced the one-child policy.
The government later relaxed the rules and even encouraged two or three children.
Birth rates continued to fall.
Key observations from Jim:
- China removed restrictions and expected a baby boom.
- The birth rate declined even faster.
- Bribes and incentives failed to produce change.
- Cultural attitudes shifted permanently during decades of low fertility.
According to the United Nations Population Division, China’s fertility rate now sits well below replacement, and the population began shrinking for the first time in six decades.
Why Did China’s Fertility Decline Continue After Ending the One Child Policy?
Jim says the answer is cultural, psychological, and deeply rooted in changing social norms.
Why Chinese Families Are Having Fewer Children
- Urbanisation increased the cost and pressure of raising a child.
- Families grew accustomed to one child as the social norm.
- Young women prioritise work and lifestyle over motherhood.
Jim describes how families with many children now face stigma.
People who want more children are looked down on. They call them pigs.
This shift in mindset, Jim explains, is almost impossible to reverse through policy alone.
Why Cultural Norms Matter More Than Policy
- Low fertility becomes socially reinforced over time.
- People adapt expectations around family size.
- Children become seen as a lifestyle burden, not a cultural value.
Even China’s propaganda campaigns cannot change deeply internalised social attitudes.
How Does China Fit Into the Global Birth Rate Crisis?
Jim says China’s collapse follows the same pattern seen in South Korea, Japan, and many Western nations.
Prosperity, not poverty, drives fertility downward.
What Patterns Link China to Other Low Fertility Countries?
- Rising wealth reduces the desire for large families.
- Small families become the norm in urban centres.
- Material comfort replaces traditional community values.
Jim explains that prosperity rewires priorities.
People have children because they want to have children. If they do not want children, no amount of persuasion will work.
According to the OECD, countries with the highest income and education levels consistently record the lowest birth rates.
What Can China Do to Address Its Demographic Collapse?
Jim believes China has very few options that can make a meaningful difference.
The nation’s treatment of religious groups also worsens the problem.
What Steps Could Have a Small Positive Effect?
- Reduce pressure on religious minorities.
- Allow cultural groups with high fertility to thrive.
- Ease restrictions on faith-based communities.
Jim notes that religious groups tend to have higher fertility, yet China actively suppresses religious expression.
Why Jim Says Technology Is the Only Real Solution
- Cultural values do not shift quickly enough to stop the collapse.
- Government propaganda cannot change psychology.
- Even strong incentives have no measurable effect on family size.
Jim believes that neuroscience and behavioural treatments will be needed to reverse the decline.
His own research into dopamine, motivation, and maternal behaviour aims to develop long term solutions.
How Could China’s Demographic Decline Affect Its Future?
China’s shrinking population will shape its political and economic future for decades.
What Jim Predicts for China’s Trajectory
- China’s economy is likely to weaken as its workforce shrinks.
- Youth behaviour already shows a declining work ethic.
- China will remain culturally strong, but less powerful globally.
Jim says China will survive as a civilisation but will face severe challenges as birth rates fall.
China will still be around in a thousand years, but it will go through a long down period.
As a point of comparison, South Korea has a fertility rate of roughly 0.7, the lowest in the world, according to the Korean Statistical Information Service.
Why is China’s birth rate falling even after ending the one-child policy?
Cultural attitudes changed during the decades of low fertility. Many families no longer want more than one child.
Can government incentives raise fertility in China?
No. Financial incentives have failed in China and in every other country that has tried them.
Why do cultural norms matter more than government policy?
Norms influence how many children people believe is acceptable. These expectations change slowly and resist policy shifts.
What role does religion play in fertility?
Religious communities tend to have higher fertility, but China restricts religious practice, which limits this effect.
Is China’s demographic collapse reversible?
Jim says only scientific breakthroughs can meaningfully reverse the decline. Cultural change alone will not be fast enough.
Key Takeaways
- China proves governments can reduce fertility, but they cannot raise it.
- Cultural attitudes toward family size are the strongest driver of fertility decline.
- Prosperity reduces the desire for children across all societies.
- Suppressing religious groups removes one of the few sources of higher fertility.
- Jim believes neuroscience is the only long-term path to reversing the global decline.
Want to hear Jim’s full insights?
Watch the podcast episode to learn why China cannot escape the global birth rate crisis and what Jim believes must change.
Interested in more updates from Jim Penman?
Visit jimpenman.com.au to join the mailing list, read new commentary, and receive updates on his upcoming book.